Is Your Olive Oil Fake? The Truth That Big Olive Doesn't Want You to Know
Neuro Athletics is a twice-weekly newsletter designed specifically for high-performing men and women who want science-backed strategies to optimize brain health, performance, and longevity. Subscribers include executives, coaches, professional women, health-conscious mothers, and women dedicated to peak cognitive and physical performance. If you're not already subscribed, join 69,000+ people who receive actionable insights directly in their inbox each week.
Story at a Glance:
Olive oil, particularly extra virgin olive oil (EVOO), has consistently been associated with longevity and reduced chronic disease risk.
The health benefits of olive oil are significantly influenced by its polyphenol content, making extra virgin olive oil superior.
Quality matters tremendously; choosing authentic extra virgin olive oil is crucial to reap health benefits.
Neuro Athletes,
As someone who is proudly Greek, I grew up with olive oil at the heart of every meal. But let's cut through the nostalgia and hype—what's the real scientific truth? Is olive oil actually a magic potion for longevity and disease prevention, or are we drowning in wishful thinking and slick marketing?
I have gathered all of the questions i have received over the past year via instagram and the podcast and collated them for you.
Let's dive in.
Today’s Newsletter Is Brought To You By Eight Sleep
I’ve been testing Sleep Elixir for a while now, and it’s quickly become a non-negotiable part of my nighttime routine.
Formulated with Valerian Root, Tart Cherry, L-Tryptophan, and Ashwagandha, it’s designed to optimize sleep architecture—helping you fall asleep faster, stay asleep longer, and wake up feeling refreshed, not groggy.
The best part? No melatonin, no dependency—just scientifically backed ingredients that work with your body’s natural sleep processes.
If you’re serious about performance, recovery, or just getting better sleep, this is worth looking into.
Does Olive Oil Really Extend Your Life?
Question: Can olive oil genuinely help you live longer, or are healthy people just more likely to consume it?
Observational studies consistently say yes—olive oil drinkers tend to live longer. But hold on, is this really about olive oil or is it about olive oil drinkers?
Turns out, even when scientists adjust for healthier habits (less smoking, less booze, more exercise), olive oil remains a winner. One landmark 2022 study from the Journal of the American College of Cardiology followed participants over 28 years. Results? Those consuming just half a tablespoon daily saw significantly lower risks of dying from heart disease, cancer, neurodegenerative diseases, and even respiratory issues.
But here's the catch: this isn't proof. It’s correlation, not causation. Still, the consistent patterns across diverse populations can't simply be ignored.
Does the type of olive oil really matter, or are we just falling for fancy labels?
The blunt truth: Yes, it matters—a lot.
Extra virgin olive oil (EVOO) isn't just "better" olive oil—it's a completely different beast packed with polyphenols (natural compounds that actively support health). A groundbreaking study in Nature found that people who regularly consumed EVOO (around 1.5 tablespoons daily) had a 30% lower risk of dying overall and a whopping 50% lower risk of dying from heart disease compared to those consuming lesser-quality oils.
Why does this happen? It’s not the fats themselves—regular and extra virgin olive oil share similar fat profiles.
The secret weapon?
Polyphenols like hydroxytyrosol that actively protect cells from damage and inflammation.
Can Olive Oil Actually Protect You from Cancer?
Question: Is olive oil an anticancer miracle, or are we cherry-picking weak data?
Frankly, the evidence here is messy.
Some observational studies report reduced cancer risk with high olive oil intake, especially gastrointestinal cancers. But these results often come from weaker studies. Stronger cohort studies generally fail to confirm this protective effect.
However, a fascinating recent study by longevity researcher Dr. Luigi Fontana offers new insights. He tracked nearly 3,000 Italians consuming premium, polyphenol-rich EVOO. Result? A striking 60% reduction in deaths from gastrointestinal cancers among heavy EVOO consumers.
What’s going on? It might be the unique polyphenols in high-quality EVOO influencing genetic pathways. This isn't proof yet, but it's a compelling signal worth paying attention to.
Does Olive Oil Keep Your Brain Sharp?
Question: Can EVOO truly protect your brain, or are we overselling olive oil’s cognitive powers?
Here's where things get genuinely interesting. The renowned Three-City Study tracked nearly 7,000 older adults and found significantly lower risks of cognitive decline among regular olive oil users. Further controlled trials have confirmed this trend, showing that EVOO consumption improves memory and cognitive abilities over the long term.
Why might EVOO protect your brain? Likely those powerful polyphenols again, enhancing brain health and possibly slowing neurodegeneration.
Olive Oil for Metabolic Health: Is This Just Fancy Fat?
Question: Why should anyone prefer olive oil over other healthy cooking oils like sunflower or corn oil?
Surprisingly, despite similar healthy fat profiles, EVOO often outperforms polyunsaturated vegetable oils when it comes to blood sugar control. Several clinical studies demonstrate that EVOO significantly improves fasting glucose levels in diabetics compared to these oils.
Why? Again, it's probably those polyphenols that modulate how your body handles sugar—another win for EVOO.
So……?
Question: Is olive oil a legitimate health powerhouse, or is this just hype cleverly spun by Big Olive?
The scientific consensus is leaning heavily towards EVOO as a legitimate health booster, particularly due to its unique bioactive compounds. This isn’t merely "healthy fat"—it’s medicinal food.
But a crucial takeaway: quality matters immensely. If you're consuming low-quality, diluted olive oil, you're probably missing out on these health perks.
Key Takeaways (For Now):
Olive oil, especially EVOO, is consistently linked with improved health and longevity.
The type of olive oil (extra virgin vs. refined) significantly impacts health benefits.
Polyphenols are the primary heroes in olive oil’s health narrative.
Next week in Part 2, we’ll tackle the murky world of olive oil fraud. Is the bottle in your pantry really EVOO, or have you been duped?
Stay skeptical. Stay informed. Stay tuned for Part 2, where we'll dive deeper into olive oil authenticity and expose how you might unknowingly be buying fraudulent products.
When you open olive oil how fast the antioxiadant drop, and its good Idea to put in the griffe? Thanks
Does when one consumes EVOO change its benefits?