Are You Paying for Expertise or Just Salesmanship?
The Truth About Fitness Trainers
Neuro Athletics is a 2 x weekly newsletter that breaks down the medical and scientific practises that you need to perform at your peak. Subscribers include professional athletes, athletic trainers, coaches and casual fans. So if you are not already a subscriber, sign up and join 69,000+ others who receive it directly in their inbox each
Story at a Glance:
Most personal trainers have minimal education, often earning a certification in just six weeks.
They are not required to have hands-on experience or deep knowledge of biomechanics, physiology, or nutrition.
High-end gyms like Equinox charge premium rates for trainers who are better at selling packages than delivering real expertise.
Poor coaching leads to injury, stagnation, and misinformation, putting clients at risk.
Neuro Athletes,
When you hire a personal trainer, you're entrusting someone with more than just your fitness goals—you're placing your overall health and wellbeing in their hands. But what if the trainer confidently instructing you has barely more than a month of education behind them?
What if the expert guiding your workouts, nutrition choices, and recovery plans is only a step ahead of you in experience and understanding?
The unsettling reality is that most trainers lack proper qualifications, leaving your health hanging in the balance. It's time to expose the hidden risk in the fitness industry and demand better.
Today’s Newsletter Is Brought To You By Eight Sleep
I’ve been testing Sleep Elixir for a while now, and it’s quickly become a non-negotiable part of my nighttime routine.
Formulated with Valerian Root, Tart Cherry, L-Tryptophan, and Ashwagandha, it’s designed to optimize sleep architecture—helping you fall asleep faster, stay asleep longer, and wake up feeling refreshed, not groggy.
The best part? No melatonin, no dependency—just scientifically backed ingredients that work with your body’s natural sleep processes.
If you’re serious about performance, recovery, or just getting better sleep, this is worth looking into.
Real question…
Have you ever wondered about the true qualifications of your personal trainer? Despite appearing fit, confident, and knowledgeable, the unsettling truth is that many trainers are undereducated, underprepared, and overconfident.
The industry standard for becoming a personal trainer often amounts to little more than a brief online course completed within weeks, leaving many trainers dangerously underqualified.
A Timeline of Minimal Standards
Here’s a shocking look at how quickly someone can become a certified personal trainer:
Day 1: Decide to become a trainer.
Week 2-4: Enroll in an online course, learning basic anatomy and exercise guidelines.
Week 6-8: Pass an online multiple-choice test—often open-book and unsupervised.
Week 9: Begin selling personal training sessions and offering advice on biomechanics, physiology, and even nutrition—despite lacking formal education in these areas.
Compare this to the rigorous education required of physical therapists or registered dietitians—professionals whose roles significantly overlap with trainers in terms of advising on health and performance. The disparity is alarming.The Equinox Problem: Sales Over Science
Equinox, a premium gym charging upwards of $150-$200 per session, exemplifies the issue. Despite their luxury branding, Equinox trainers frequently prioritize sales tactics over actual expertise. Many are fresh out of short-term certification programs, skilled in upselling but lacking meaningful knowledge in physiology, biomechanics, or evidence-based nutrition.
The consequence? Trainers routinely prescribe exercises based on trends rather than science, increasing clients’ risk of injury and diminishing the overall effectiveness of workouts.
The Real-Life Impact of Poor Training
Poorly designed programs can lead to significant health setbacks, including:
Injuries due to inappropriate exercise prescription.
Plateaus and burnout from poorly structured training.
Misguided dietary advice causing metabolic issues or unhealthy eating behaviors.
A recent study revealed that over 70% of personal trainers fail basic assessments of biomechanics. In other words, your trainer might be one poorly executed squat away from causing serious injury.
The Solution: Elevating Industry Standards
It’s time to expect more from personal trainers. Truly effective coaches should have:
Formal education in exercise science, physiology, kinesiology, or a related field.
Hands-on, supervised training and practical assessments.
Deep understanding of biomechanics, injury prevention, physiology, and nutrition.
Ongoing education that keeps them up-to-date with current research and best practices.
Neuro Athletics Coaching Certificate (NACC): Raising the Bar
Innovative programs, like the Neuro Athletics Coaching Certificate (NACC), represent the future of fitness education by emphasizing comprehensive, evidence-based learning in areas such as neuroscience, exercise physiology, and performance optimization. Programs like these are not simply credentials—they’re pathways to genuinely understanding human performance and longevity.
What You Can Do Right Now
When choosing a trainer, ask critical questions:
What is your formal education background in exercise science?
Can you explain your training approach scientifically?
How do you personalize your programs?
What continuing education have you pursued recently?
When and how do you refer clients to specialists?
Unsatisfactory answers should prompt you to look elsewhere.
Until the fitness industry raises its standards, your best defense is skepticism and discernment. Demand trainers who prioritize science over salesmanship, and education over aesthetics. Your health and longevity depend on making the right choice.
Stay infofmed,
Louisa
Please set up in Syd, Australia Nicola. We need you!! PT's run amok here with no real idea how to train anyone with multiple injuries. I've incurred injuries FROM PT's. From experience - they are not interested in training over 50 and/or with injuries. It's too boring for them! There's such an untapped market here and all the mainstream gyms are clearly missing it.
I have never used a personal trainer, but have to say here in America, at least, any sort of nutritional advice from anyone associated with allopathic medicine, especially registered dieticians, is a direct route to metabolic disorders and worse. We have an entire generation of middle aged people who have had their insulin disregulated by polyunsaturated fats(vegetable and seed oils), which were promoted as heart healthy. Starved of cholesterol and given stains so they could have a much reduced mental function, and encouraged to avoid salt and sip water all the time so they have low brain sodium. Those seed oils also lower your metabolism and body temperature so you get obiesity so the Doctors can sell you Ozembic. I would have avoided all sorts of trouble had I gone by what uneducated people who are champion weightlifters showed me as a teen, rather than following bad nutritional advice from M.D.s.